Do Greater Manchester care providers and contractors need key person or shareholder protection?

Many Greater Manchester care providers and contractors need both covers, because the two risks are different. A care provider with one registered manager depends on that person to keep its Care Quality Commission registration in place. A contractor can depend on one accredited supervisor to keep a framework position or a tender live. Key person cover insures the business against losing a person it depends on to do the work: the proceeds go to the company, to cover lost income and the cost of a replacement. A company with two or three shareholders holding the shares directly, and no stock market to sell into, needs shareholder protection so the surviving shareholders have the money to buy a deceased owner's share from the estate, without taking on a new co-owner they did not choose.

What a registered manager or an accredited supervisor controls

A care provider's Care Quality Commission registration
A provider registered with the Care Quality Commission needs a registered manager in post for its regulated activities. If that person leaves without notice, the provider has to tell the CQC and appoint a replacement, and the registration itself is put at risk until it does.
A contractor's accreditation or framework position
A tender, a framework agreement or a safety accreditation scheme can name a specific qualified person, such as a site manager holding a current CITB or SSIP qualification. Losing that person without a replacement already trained can put the contract itself at risk.

See business protection for how critical illness cover can be added to the same lives.

A worked example in Greater Manchester

A domiciliary care company based in Bolton has three directors, each holding a third of the shares. One of the three is the registered manager named on the company's Care Quality Commission registration. The company takes out key person cover of £80,000 on the registered manager, set against the combined cost of six months of locum management fees and a recruitment campaign for a replacement. Separately, each of the three directors is covered for £250,000 under a cross-option agreement, set against an illustrative company valuation of £750,000 split three ways, so a departing shareholder's estate has a buyer for their third lined up and paid for in cash.

A groundworks and civil engineering contractor based in Salford has two director-shareholders and an illustrative company value of £1.2 million. Each director is covered for £600,000 under the same kind of agreement. The company separately insures its lead estimator, the person named on the accreditation that keeps the firm eligible to tender for local authority work, for £50,000: the cost of retraining and requalifying a replacement while a new tender round is missed.

What key person cover and shareholder protection each do

Who the proceeds go to
Key person cover pays the company. Shareholder protection pays the surviving shareholders, who use the money to buy the deceased owner's share from the estate under a cross-option agreement.
How the cross-option agreement works
A cross-option agreement gives the surviving shareholders an option to buy a departing shareholder's shares, and gives the departing shareholder or their estate an option to sell. Neither side is bound to complete the sale while the shareholder is alive, so HM Revenue and Customs does not treat the shares as sold under a binding contract and business property relief stays available on the estate.
Tax treatment of the premiums
Key person cover taken to protect profits may attract corporation tax relief on the premiums, subject to the wholly and exclusively test HM Revenue and Customs applies to any business expense. Cover protecting a shareholding normally does not, because the benefit belongs to the shareholder personally and is not a cost of running the business. Confirm the position with your accountant before the policy is put in place.
The valuation behind the figure
A cross-option agreement needs an up-to-date valuation of the shares. Cover set years ago against an old figure can leave the survivors short of the price they now need to pay. Check the valuation and the cover together.

A relevant life policy insures an individual employee's death in service for their own family: see what is a relevant life policy. Key person cover and shareholder protection insure the business and its shareholders, and the three can run side by side.

What to check this week

  • List who the business could not run without. A registered manager, a qualified supervisor, or an estimator who holds the accreditation a tender depends on.
  • Get a current valuation of the shares. A valuation from when the company was set up is normally out of date.
  • Check the shareholders' or partnership agreement for a cross-option clause. An agreement that obliges the survivors to buy only works if the money to do it is already in place.
  • Ask your accountant how the premiums would be treated. Key person cover and shareholder protection are taxed differently, and the company's structure decides which applies.

A company with three shareholders and no listed market needs a buyer for a departing owner's share lined up before the day it is needed.

Related questions

Is key person cover the same as shareholder protection?

No, they cover different things. Key person cover pays the business when it loses someone whose work it depends on, such as a registered manager or an accredited supervisor, and the money covers lost income and the cost of a replacement. Shareholder protection pays the surviving shareholders when an owner dies, so they have the cash to buy that person's shares from the estate under a cross-option agreement. A company can need one without the other: a sole shareholder who is also the key person needs key person cover but has no co-owner to protect against, and a passive shareholder who does no work in the business needs share protection but is not a key person.

Does the Care Quality Commission require us to have this insurance?

No, there is no regulatory requirement to hold either policy. The Care Quality Commission requires a care provider to have a registered manager in post for its regulated activities, and losing that person without a plan for a replacement can put the registration itself at risk. Key person cover does not satisfy that requirement on its own, because the business still needs a suitably qualified person registered with the CQC. What the cover does is fund the locum management and recruitment costs while a new registered manager is found and approved, so the business has the time and the money to meet the requirement itself.

Can a two-person company use shareholder protection?

Yes, a cross-option agreement works for two shareholders in the same way it works for three or more. Each director takes out, or the company takes out on their behalf, a policy sized to their share of the company's value, held under an agreement that gives the survivor an option to buy and the deceased's estate an option to sell. If one director dies, the survivor receives the sum insured and uses it to buy the shares from the estate. The family receives a cash payment for the shares, and the surviving director becomes the sole owner.

What does key person cover pay for if a contractor's estimator dies?

It pays the company a lump sum sized to the cost of replacing that person's role. For a contracting business, the figure normally covers recruitment, a higher salary needed to attract someone qualified quickly, and the cost of retraining or requalifying them against whatever accreditation the business holds, such as a safety scheme membership a tender depends on. The sum is agreed when the policy is arranged, based on a reasonable estimate of those costs. It does not adjust automatically as the business grows, so review it as the company and its contracts change.

Is the premium for shareholder protection tax deductible?

Normally not. HM Revenue and Customs applies the wholly and exclusively test to any premium a company claims as a business expense, and cover that protects a shareholding is normally treated as providing a personal benefit to the shareholder, so the premium is not an allowable deduction for corporation tax. Key person cover taken purely to protect the company's profits sits on different ground and may attract relief, because the benefit there belongs to the business and not to an individual shareholder. Confirm your own arrangement with your accountant before the policy starts, because the structure decides the answer.

We already have a shareholders' agreement. Do we still need the insurance?

Yes, because the agreement and the money behind it are two separate things. A shareholders' agreement can set out that the survivors must buy a departing owner's shares, but it does not provide the cash to pay for them, and a company forced to find a large sum quickly can end up selling assets or borrowing on poor terms to meet an obligation it has already signed up to. The insurance is what supplies that cash. Check the agreement and the cover together, so the amount insured matches what the agreement commits the survivors to pay.

Does Buzz Financial Services arrange this cover directly?

Yes, the advisers at Equity & General arrange key person cover and shareholder protection as part of business protection advice, working alongside your accountant and, where one exists, your solicitor on the shareholders' agreement. We consider a sufficiently broad and diverse range of relevant products and providers across the market, subject to the scope of the service we provide. The levels of cover are set against your own figures and agreed with you before anything is arranged. Bring any shareholders' or partnership agreement you already have to the first meeting, so the cover and the agreement can be checked against each other from the start.

Calculators

Where this fits

Bring any shareholders' or partnership agreement you have, and we will work out how much cover each part of it needs.

Talk to an adviser

Your first call is with an Account Manager and is at no cost to you. Tell us what is on your mind: a pension you have lost track of, a fixed rate ending, a will you keep meaning to write.